Nigeria’s political landscape is heating up once again this time with a legal twist. A Federal High Court in Abuja has set June 25 as the date to hear a lawsuit filed by the Department of State Services (DSS) against Professor Pat Utomi, a prominent political economist and opposition figure. The reason? His recently launched “shadow government.”
The suit, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/937/2025, stems from Utomi’s May 5 announcement of a virtual shadow government under the Big Tent Coalition—a group he says is aimed at providing a credible opposition to the administration of President Bola Tinubu. But while shadow governments are not unusual in parliamentary democracies as symbolic checks on ruling parties, Nigeria’s secret police view this differently.
The DSS contends that Utomi’s initiative violates the Nigerian constitution and could destabilize the nation. In its filing, the agency warned that the creation of such a parallel structure may encourage unrest, fuel inter-group tensions, and embolden separatist or unlawful actors to establish similar bodies.
According to court documents, the DSS is asking for several declarations and injunctions:
- That the formation of a shadow government is unconstitutional and represents an attempt to create an alternative authority outside the Nigerian legal framework.
- That Sections 1(1), 1(2), and 14(2)(a) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) do not permit the establishment of any governmental body outside those created by law.
- And, crucially, that a perpetual injunction should be issued preventing Utomi and his associates from taking further steps to operate any such parallel institution.
At a recent hearing, Justice James Omotosho granted a request from DSS counsel Akinlolu Kehinde to serve court papers on Utomi via courier, as previous attempts to deliver the documents directly to his Lagos address had failed.
For his part, Utomi has framed the shadow government as a democratic tool meant to hold the current administration accountable, rather than a threat to national unity. However, the DSS clearly sees it as a red flag—perhaps even a warning shot for other opposition figures considering similar moves.
This case raises pressing questions: Where does healthy political opposition end and unconstitutional behavior begin? Can Nigeria make space for more creative forms of dissent without risking instability? And what does this legal battle mean for the state of free expression and opposition politics in the country?
All eyes now turn to June 25, when the court will begin hearing arguments. One thing is certain—this isn’t just a legal fight. It’s a test of Nigeria’s democratic boundaries.

