Manchester United great Paul Scholes has launched a stinging criticism of Arsenal, insisting the Gunners would rank as the poorest side to win the Premier League if they eventually claim the title this season.
Arsenal remain top of the table with a four-point advantage, but their grip on the lead weakened over the weekend after a defeat to Manchester United. The result allowed Manchester City and Aston Villa to close the gap, further intensifying the title race.
Mikel Arteta’s men have managed only two points from their last three league outings, finding the net just twice in that run — both goals coming against United. Despite leading the standings, recent performances have raised doubts about their cutting edge.
Scholes, speaking on The Good, The Bad & The Football podcast, questioned Arsenal’s overall quality, particularly in attack.
“If Arsenal go on to win the league, they could be the worst team to do it,” Scholes said. “If you’re picking a team of the season and looking at the front four, you wouldn’t select anyone from Arsenal.”
While acknowledging Bukayo Saka as their standout option, the former England midfielder argued that even the winger has not been convincing enough this campaign.
“Saka is probably the only one you’d consider, but even he hasn’t been outstanding. His goals and assists numbers aren’t great,” Scholes added.
Arsenal’s heavy reliance on set-pieces has also attracted criticism. United winger Amad Diallo recently suggested that corners were the Gunners’ main attacking threat, a claim that aligns with growing concerns over their open-play creativity.
Although Arsenal have scored 42 league goals — second only to Manchester City — several key attackers are enduring prolonged goal droughts. Bukayo Saka has failed to score in his last 13 appearances across all competitions, while Viktor Gyökeres has not netted from open play in 11 league games. Gabriel Martinelli is also without a league goal in 13 matches.
Other attacking options have similarly struggled. Noni Madueke has gone 25 Premier League games without scoring, while Leandro Trossard has managed just one goal in his last 11 appearances in all competitions.
Despite these issues, Arsenal have been devastating from dead-ball situations, scoring 26 set-piece goals this season — the highest tally across Europe’s top five leagues. However, critics argue that this strength has masked deficiencies elsewhere on the pitch.
Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher has echoed Scholes’ concerns, suggesting Arsenal’s dependence on set-pieces could limit them in the decisive stages of the title race.
As the season heads into a critical phase, Arsenal’s credentials as champions remain under intense scrutiny despite their position at the summit.

