The Federal High Court in Abuja has struck out a suit seeking to compel the Independent National Electoral Commission to recognise and publish the names of the Kabiru Turaki-led interim National Working Committee of the Peoples Democratic Party.
Justice Salim Ibrahim, in a judgment delivered on Friday, held that the plaintiffs lacked the legal standing to institute the action and that the suit was incompetent.
The judge also upheld preliminary objections filed by INEC and members of the Wike-backed PDP leadership before striking out the case.
The suit was filed by the Chairman of the PDP Board of Trustees, Adolphus Wabara, alongside other BoT members and party stakeholders.
The plaintiffs had asked the court to declare that INEC was constitutionally bound to recognise the Turaki-led interim NWC, publish the names of its members on its website and accept official communications from the body.
They relied on Section 287 of the Constitution and Article 32(5)(a)(i) of the PDP Constitution, arguing that previous judgments of the Federal Capital Territory High Court, the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court required INEC to recognise the interim leadership.
However, Justice Ibrahim held that the plaintiffs failed to establish any existing legal obligation requiring INEC to recognise the purported interim NWC.
“The plaintiffs’ case therefore depends on whether there remains an undisputed legal obligation on INEC to recognise the alleged Interim National Working Committee,” the judge said.
The court also held that the plaintiffs failed to prove that INEC had previously recognised the Turaki-led body or that any subsisting court order directed the electoral commission to recognise it.
Justice Ibrahim further ruled that the Supreme Court judgment relied upon by the plaintiffs did not constitute an order compelling INEC to recognise the interim NWC.
He also held that the plaintiffs failed to establish that the Turaki-led body constituted the lawful leadership of the PDP with authority to represent the party in dealings with INEC.
Consequently, the court upheld INEC’s preliminary objection and ruled that the first to seventh plaintiffs lacked the requisite locus standi to institute and maintain the action.
The judge also upheld objections filed by parties who sought to join the suit.
The court had earlier granted applications by members of the Wike-backed PDP leadership to join the case as defendants. They included Abdulrahman Mohammed, identified as the faction’s national chairman, Senator Samuel Anyanwu, the national secretary, and the party’s National Legal Adviser, Kamaldeen Ajibade.
The court also joined Austin Nwachukwu, Abraham Amah Nnanna and George Turnah as necessary parties whose interests could be affected by the outcome of the case.
Justice Ibrahim, however, granted an application seeking to strike out the PDP as the eighth plaintiff.
He held that the objections filed by the newly joined defendants had merit, ruling that the suit sought to reopen issues already determined in another case.
Having resolved the preliminary issues against the plaintiffs, the judge held that the court lacked jurisdiction to hear the originating summons and struck out the suit.
He also awarded N10 million in costs against the plaintiffs in favour of the defendants.
The judge directed the counsel who filed the action to personally pay the N10 million costs, saying the order was intended to discourage frivolous political litigation.
“The court shall be awarding N10m costs against the plaintiffs to all the defendants, to the 1st to the 7th defendants.
“The counsel on record that filed this matter is also to do the needful, and pay N10 million costs,” Justice Ibrahim held.
The judge said the order was made to discourage frivolous applications in what he described as an internal affair of the political party.
The judgment represents a setback for the Wabara-led Board of Trustees’ effort to secure judicial backing for the recognition of the Turaki-led interim NWC.
The case formed part of the prolonged leadership crisis within the PDP, which has pitted the party’s Board of Trustees against the camp loyal to the Minister of the Federal Capital Territory, Nyesom Wike, over control of the party’s national leadership.

