Former England national football team striker Gary Lineker has suggested there may be underlying tension behind recent criticism directed at Michael Carrick by his former Manchester United teammate, Paul Scholes.
Carrick stepped in as interim manager following the departure of Ruben Amorim in November last year and enjoyed a strong start in the role. His early success prompted discussions among supporters and pundits about whether he should be considered for the club’s permanent managerial position.
However, several former Manchester United players, including Gary Neville, Roy Keane and Scholes, have argued that the club should look elsewhere and conduct a broader search for a long-term manager.
While much of the criticism has been framed as football analysis, some remarks have attracted controversy. Keane previously drew criticism after referencing Carrick’s wife during his assessment of the interim manager and has repeatedly insisted that the club should not appoint Carrick permanently regardless of results.
Scholes also came under fire following Manchester United’s defeat to Newcastle United, when he posted a sarcastic message on social media that appeared to mock Carrick. Although the post was later deleted, it drew backlash from supporters who viewed the comments as unnecessarily negative.
Former Manchester United defender Patrice Evra criticised Scholes, Keane and Neville for what he described as overly harsh analysis of Carrick, suggesting the remarks were aimed at generating media attention.
Speaking on The Rest Is Football podcast, Lineker speculated that Scholes’ criticism could be linked to a past disagreement between the two former teammates.
“You see, there’s a little bit of beef between Paul Scholes and Michael Carrick?” Lineker said. “He’s digging him out, isn’t he? He’s not exactly being very supportive of his old teammate, is he?”
The 65-year-old added that the situation appeared unusual, suggesting there could be historical issues between the pair.
Scholes and Carrick played 160 matches together for Manchester United between 2006 and 2013. During that period, the club won several major honours, including five Premier League titles and the UEFA Champions League.

