Nigerian President Bola Tinubu has urged a United States court to reject a bid to force the release of federal investigative records naming him, arguing the material is shielded by American privacy law.
According to a report by TheCable, Tinubu—who has joined the case as an intervenor—set out his position in a filing submitted on Friday to the US District Court for the District of Columbia. He is asking the court to dismiss a motion for summary judgment brought by Aaron Greenspan, founder of the transparency platform PlainSite, and to let the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) keep existing redactions in place.
Background to the case
Greenspan had filed a series of Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests dating back to 2022 and 2023, seeking records from several US agencies tied to a Chicago heroin-trafficking case from the early 1990s. Tinubu was one of four people named in the requests, alongside Lee Andrew Edwards, Mueez Abegboyega Akande and Abiodun Agbele.
Some agencies initially refused to confirm or deny holding any such records. However, in April 2025, US District Judge Beryl Howell ruled that the FBI and DEA had not shown sufficient grounds to keep secret the mere fact that Tinubu had once been under investigation, and ordered both agencies to search for and process relevant, non-exempt files. The CIA’s refusal to confirm or deny the existence of records was allowed to stand.
The FBI and DEA went on to hand over thousands of pages, many with sections blacked out, along with an index explaining the reasons for the withholdings. Greenspan later asked the court to compel fuller disclosure, arguing the material provided fell short of what his requests covered.
Tinubu’s argument
In the new filing, Tinubu’s legal team contends that FOIA exists to shed light on how government agencies operate, not to hand over what one lawyer’s brief described, according to TheCable, as information the government collected about private individuals. The president’s lawyers point to a 1989 US Supreme Court ruling holding that releasing records on private citizens generally does little to illuminate government conduct.
They argue the redacted passages are protected under a FOIA exemption covering law-enforcement records whose release could amount to an unwarranted invasion of privacy, as well as under the US Privacy Act.
Tinubu’s lawyers also dispute Greenspan’s claim that Judge Howell’s 2025 ruling stripped away the president’s privacy rights over the files’ contents. They say the judge drew a distinction between confirming that an investigation took place and releasing what the investigation actually found—and that her ruling addressed only the former. They further argue that some previously public details about Tinubu’s past do not cancel out his privacy interest in material that remains undisclosed.
On the question of public interest, Tinubu’s team rejects the idea that his position as Nigeria’s president automatically justifies disclosure, arguing that curiosity about an official’s background or suitability for office is not the kind of public interest FOIA is designed to serve. They also dismiss suggestions of a cover-up or secret prosecution as unproven claims that cannot compel release of the records.
The president denies any wrongdoing in connection with the case.
Tinubu’s filing asks the court to deny Greenspan’s motion and to leave the FBI and DEA’s redactions untouched. The case continues before the District Court for the District of Columbia.
This report draws on reporting first published by TheCable.

